Edgewonk or The Trader's Hindsight?
Both are trading journals that read your trades and show you where they go wrong. Edgewonk is a paid journal with deep analytics for many markets. The Trader's Hindsight is built for forex and prop-firm traders. It is free to start and shows you what your trading habits cost you.
Everything this page says about Edgewonk was read on its own site on 11 November 2026.
| What is compared | The Trader's Hindsight | Edgewonk |
|---|---|---|
| Price and platforms | ||
| Price | The Trader's HindsightFree, then $12, $18 or $28 a month. Pay yearly and two months are free. | Edgewonk$35 a month, or $197 for 12 months, with every feature on both. VAT is added in the EU and the UK. |
| Free plan | The Trader's HindsightYes, with cTrader auto-sync, file import, manual entry, analytics and the Hindsight Report. | EdgewonkNo. Both plans are paid, with your money back within 14 days if you are not satisfied. |
| Markets | The Trader's HindsightForex and prop-firm accounts on MetaTrader, cTrader, TradeLocker, DXtrade and MatchTrader. | EdgewonkForex, stocks, futures, crypto, options, indices and commodities. |
| Auto-sync | The Trader's HindsightcTrader on every plan, the free one included. One MetaTrader account on Pro and Elite, two on Master, and more at $6 a month each. Every connection is read-only, so it can never place, modify or close a trade. | EdgewonkMetaTrader 4 and 5 at any broker or prop firm, with unlimited accounts. cTrader is supported too. |
| Import and accounts | The Trader's HindsightStatements from MT5, cTrader, TradeLocker, DXtrade and MatchTrader, or trades typed in by hand. Unlimited manual accounts. See each account on its own or all of them added together on one dashboard. Export your whole history whenever you like. | EdgewonkUnlimited journals, accounts and imports from hundreds of brokers, and a portfolio page that shows all your journals together. You can export your journal at any time. |
| The journal | ||
| Each trade | The Trader's HindsightEvery trade is tagged as it lands, with its session and any habit it shows, such as revenge or oversizing. You review it against your setup's checklist, with notes, an emotion, a lesson and screenshots from before and after. | EdgewonkYour own tags and comments, setup checklists that track which criteria each trade met, and screenshots on every trade. |
| Analytics | The Trader's HindsightAn equity curve, a calendar, win rate, profit factor, expectancy, R-multiples and streaks, with your results by hour, session, weekday and month. | EdgewonkTime performance, a profit calendar, performance ratios, drawdown, losing streaks, risk analysis and how your win rate develops. |
| Reports | The Trader's HindsightA monthly report with your drawdown. On the paid plans, a digest of last week's habits every Monday, on Telegram and by email. | EdgewonkWeekly and monthly performance reports, and a scan every Sunday for your edge and your mistakes. |
| An AI coach | The Trader's HindsightInsight answers your questions and reviews your trades from your own record, on the paid plans. | EdgewonkNone is named on its features or pricing pages. |
| Sharing | The Trader's HindsightOnce your journal holds 30 days of trades, a Track-Record Passport shows your stats on a public page at a handle you choose. You can also save the habit that costs you the most as a picture to post. | EdgewonkShare a journal with a mentor or a friend, read-only, and take the access back at any time. |
| Habits, rules and prop firms | ||
| What your habits cost | The Trader's HindsightThe Hindsight Report counts your month again without each habit and ranks the habits by what they cost you. | EdgewonkMistake tracking, and a Tiltmeter that shows how often you break your rules. It shows how much your trading errors cost you. |
| Your rules | The Trader's HindsightCommit to a fix as a rule with one tap. Every new trade is checked against it, and the report shows what keeping to it saved you. On Master, Commitment Mode sends a Telegram alert the moment a trade breaks it on an account Foresight watches. | EdgewonkTrading plans, a count of how often you follow your rules and which ones earn you the most, and instant feedback when you break one. |
| Prop firms | The Trader's HindsightEach challenge or funded account shows how close you are to the profit target, the loss room left today and overall, your trading days and any best-day cap the firm sets. | EdgewonkUnlimited prop firm accounts, each in a journal of its own at no extra cost. |
Where Edgewonk does more
- It journals stocks, futures, crypto and options as well as forex.
- MAE and MFE, a trade management optimiser and a performance simulator.
- Strategy testing and missed trade tracking.
- Psychology analysis, session report cards and a trading diary.
- Unlimited MetaTrader accounts for one price.
- More than ten years of helping traders.
Where The Trader's Hindsight does more
- Foresight, which reads a trade you plan against your rules, your history and the news calendar before you place it, on the paid plans.
- Real-time Foresight, which watches an account around the clock and sends a read to Telegram as you open each trade. It comes with the paid plans, at no extra cost on cTrader and $18 a month for each MetaTrader account.
- A news briefing each morning on Telegram, with the day's high-impact events for the currencies you trade, on the paid plans.
- Copy trade, which records one trade on several accounts at once, each with its own result, free. The Hindsight Report counts the copies as one decision.
- A Prop career ledger of every challenge fee, refund and payout, so you know if you are up or down at each firm, overall and year by year, free.
- Firm Fit, your odds of passing at each prop firm from your own trades, free and with no account.
- A page for each prop firm with its challenge rules and the date each was last checked, free.
- Firm Watch, which reads the prop firms' rules every day and tells you on Telegram or by email when a firm you trade at changes them, on every plan.
Which one suits you?
If you trade stocks, futures or options as well as forex, or you want every analytics tool for one price, Edgewonk covers more ground. If you trade forex or prop-firm challenges and want to find the habit that costs you the most and stop it, start here for free.
Read on 11 November 2026 at edgewonk.com/pricing, edgewonk.com/features, edgewonk.com/import and edgewonk.com/forex-trading-journal. Prices and features change, so check Edgewonk's site before you choose. The Trader's Hindsight has no connection with Edgewonk.